Man sentenced to life for murder in Tallaght park
Ioan Artene Bob, a 49-year-old Romanian construction worker of no fixed abode, was found badly beaten in Sean Walsh Memorial Park, Tallaght, Dublin, on the morning of 13 April 2018 and later died in hospital from blunt force trauma. Feri Anghel, a Romanian man of no fixed abode, was charged with his murder and pleaded not guilty. A first trial at the Central Criminal Court in 2021 ended with a hung jury, and a second trial before Mr Justice Paul Burns concluded on 14 April 2022 with a unanimous guilty verdict after three hours and 44 minutes of deliberation. On 30 May 2022, Anghel was sentenced to a mandatory life sentence, backdated to 18 April 2018.
- Reportednot reported
- Arrestednot reported
- Chargednot reported
- In court8 Jul
16 reports - Convicted14 Apr
3 reports - Sentenced30 May
2 reports
Key facts
consolidated from all reports- What happened
- Ioan Artene Bob, a 49-year-old Romanian construction worker of no fixed abode, was found badly beaten in Sean Walsh Memorial Park, Tallaght, Dublin 24, on the morning of 13 April 2018 and later died in hospital from extensive blunt force trauma.
- Bob had won around €2,700 at a casino in Dublin city centre on 9 April 2018 and sent the bulk of the winnings to his family in Romania before the attack.
- CCTV showed Bob and Anghel travelling together on a Luas tram to Tallaght shortly after midnight on 12 April, and a man similar to Anghel was later seen using Bob's bank card at an ATM in Tallaght and at shops in Slane, Co Meath.
- Cause
- The pathologist found injuries consistent with punching, kicking and stamping, including multiple rib fractures, collapsed lungs, and bruising to the outer surface of the heart.
- Charges
- Feri Anghel, a Romanian man of no fixed abode, was charged with murdering Bob on 13 April 2018 and pleaded not guilty.
- In court
- A first trial at the Central Criminal Court in 2021 ended with a hung jury after three months, and a second trial before Mr Justice Paul Burns concluded on 14 April 2022 with a unanimous guilty verdict after three hours and 44 minutes of deliberation.
- Sentence
- Anghel was sentenced to a mandatory life sentence on 30 May 2022, backdated to 18 April 2018.
- Other details
- Bob had a child in Romania and sent money home regularly; he had been sleeping in his car and later in a sleeping bag in the docks area of Dublin.
- Anghel had 24 previous convictions from Romania, France and Ireland, including attempted murder in Romania.
- Investigation
- There was no DNA, fingerprint, fibre or weapon evidence linking Anghel to the scene; the prosecution's case was circumstantial, relying on CCTV, phone proximity data, and bank card transactions.
290 statements extracted from the articles
- whatBob told Dumitru two days before his death that he hit the jackpot at a casino, winning over €2,500 using a €2 coin he had found. (longfordleader.ie)
- whatBob was drunk and asked Dumitru for a knife the night before he was found beaten. (longfordleader.ie)
- whatBob died in hospital from extensive blunt force trauma with multiple fractures and bruising to his lungs and the outer surface of the heart. (longfordleader.ie)
- whatThe blunt force trauma suggested multiple blows of a fist, kicks and stamping-type injuries, some inflicted when Bob was curled up and lying down. (longfordleader.ie)
- whatDumitru got to know Bob through his work as a labourer and described him as decent and a very good friend. (longfordleader.ie)
- whatBob was sleeping in his car, which was then seized by gardaí, and he moved to another car parked near Busáras in Dublin 1. (longfordleader.ie)
- whatBob had an eight-year-old daughter in Spain and sent money to support her. (longfordleader.ie)
- whatBob ended up sleeping in a sleeping bag he would hide during the day in the area of the docks. (longfordleader.ie)
- whatBob went to a casino on Eden Quay with €2 and won over €2,500. (longfordleader.ie)
- whatBob was with friends and drinking when Dumitru saw him outside the casino. (longfordleader.ie)
- whatBob asked Dumitru if he had a knife at a nearby Indian shop; Dumitru said no and thought it was for food. (longfordleader.ie)
- whatThey met on Moore Street where Bob was drunk with friends from Romania, and Dumitru left because Bob did not speak nicely to him. (longfordleader.ie)
- whatDumitru learned of Bob's hospitalisation and death the next day from co-workers. (longfordleader.ie)
- whatWitness Marian Dumitru told the Central Criminal Court that two days before Bob died, his friend said he hit the jackpot by winning over €2,500 at a casino using a €2 coin he had found. (kildarenow.com)
- whatMarian Dumitru told the court that Bob was drunk and had asked him for a knife on the night before he was found badly beaten in a Dublin park. (kildarenow.com)
- whatIoan Artene Bob, 49, a construction worker, was found in a park in Tallaght, Dublin 24, on the morning of 13 April 2018, and later died in hospital due to his injuries. (kildarenow.com)
- whatThe jury heard that the blunt force trauma suggested multiple blows of a fist, kicks and stamping-type injuries, while some injuries were inflicted when the deceased was curled up and lying down. (kildarenow.com)
- whatProsecution counsel Paul Greene SC said Bob was found in physical distress by passers-by in Sean Walsh Park in Tallaght after being seriously assaulted. (kildarenow.com)
- whatMarian Dumitru said he got to know Bob through his work as a labourer and that Bob was decent and a very good friend who had given him food and money. (kildarenow.com)
- whatBob had been sleeping in his car but on his first day at work he had given Dumitru lunch. (kildarenow.com)
- whatBob had his car seized by gardaí and then had to move into another car which he parked near Busáras in Dublin 1. (kildarenow.com)
- whatBob had an eight-year-old daughter in Spain at the time and sent money to her to support her. (kildarenow.com)
- whatBob ended up sleeping in a sleeping bag that he would hide during the day in the area of the docks. (kildarenow.com)
- whatTwo days before Bob died, he told Dumitru he had gotten lucky when he found €2 and went to a casino where he hit the jackpot. (kildarenow.com)
- whatDumitru went to a nearby Indian shop for food and was joined by Bob, who asked him if he had a knife; Dumitru said he did not and thought at the time it was for food. (kildarenow.com)
- whatBob sent cash from a casino jackpot win to his brother abroad the day before he was killed (irishtimes.com)
- whatBob told Ciocirla he had €400 in his wallet to last him the month (irishtimes.com)
- whatBob paid back €60 that he owed to Ciocirla (irishtimes.com)
- whatBob was sleeping in his car (irishtimes.com)
- whatIoan Artene Bob was a 49-year-old Romanian construction worker of no fixed abode. (thejournal.ie)
- whatBob later died in hospital due to his injuries. (thejournal.ie)
- whatFeri Anghel, aged 40, was also of no fixed abode and pleaded not guilty to murdering Bob. (thejournal.ie)
- whatA phone attributed to Bob and his bank card were used at locations around Dublin and Slane, Co Meath, after Bob was taken to hospital. (thejournal.ie)
- whatFormer Deputy State Pathologist Dr Margaret Bolster gave evidence that Bob suffered blunt-force trauma injuries caused by kicking, punching and stamping. (thejournal.ie)
- whatBob sustained multiple rib fractures and both his lungs had collapsed. (thejournal.ie)
- whatBoth phones accessed a cell site in Dublin on 13 April within nine minutes of each other and after Bob had passed away. (thejournal.ie)
- whatBob was a father, a brother and a brother-in-law who was living in homelessness in Dublin while working in construction to earn money to send back to his family in Romania. (thejournal.ie)
- whatBob had been living in a car in the docks area of Dublin but towards the end of his life he lived out of a rucksack. (thejournal.ie)
- whatBoth Anghel and Bob were identified by witnesses who viewed Luas footage of two men travelling to Tallaght just after midnight. (thejournal.ie)
- whatWhen Bob was discovered by walkers just after 7am in Sean Walsh Park, he was without his phone, bank card and any cash. (thejournal.ie)
- whatBob had won around €2,700 at a casino in Dublin city centre earlier that week. (thejournal.ie)
- whatWitness Viorica Ciocirla met Bob on Thursday to collect the money and saw the €400 he kept for himself in his wallet. (thejournal.ie)
- whatThe male at the ATM wore a similar jacket to the male captured on CCTV travelling with Bob on the Luas. (thejournal.ie)
- whatFeri Anghel is 40 years old (kilkennypeople.ie)
- whatIoan Artene Bob was a 49-year-old Romanian national (kilkennypeople.ie)
- whatAnghel was described during the trial as a Romani gypsy (kilkennypeople.ie)
- whatWhen found injured and dying in Sean Walsh Park at about 7:30am, Artene Bob had no cash, no phone and his ATM card was missing (kilkennypeople.ie)
- whatA man uncannily similar to the accused was captured at The Square in Tallaght attempting to withdraw cash using the deceased's bank card (kilkennypeople.ie)
- whatThe following day the accused used Artene Bob's ATM card to make two tap transactions at a Gala shop and a Topaz garage in Slane, Co Meath (kilkennypeople.ie)
- whatThe accused lied to gardaí when interviewed as a suspect (kilkennypeople.ie)
- whatThe woman who found Artene Bob asked who did this to him and he put up four fingers (kilkennypeople.ie)
- whatBob was still alive but had suffered extensive injuries when found. (irishtimes.com, kildarenow.com, kilkennypeople.ie)
- whatBob was taken to hospital and died later the same day. (irishtimes.com, kildarenow.com, kilkennypeople.ie)
- whatThe injuries suggested Bob had been stamped on, punched and kicked. (irishtimes.com)
- whatBob's ribs were fractured and he had internal lacerations. (irishtimes.com)
- whatBob was just short of his 50th birthday when he died. (irishtimes.com)
- whatBob was a Romanian national who worked in construction and sent money to his family back home. (irishtimes.com)
- whatThere was evidence Bob was carrying €400 in his wallet before he died. (irishtimes.com)
- whatWhen found, Bob had no money and his phone and ATM card were missing. (irishtimes.com)
- whatCCTV showed Bob and the accused travelling to Tallaght on a Luas tram shortly after midnight on the night of his death. (irishtimes.com)
- whatFurther CCTV showed two people uncannily similar to the accused and Bob walking towards Sean Walsh Park. (irishtimes.com)
- whatBob's injuries suggested he had been stamped on, punched and kicked. (kildarenow.com, kilkennypeople.ie)
- whatDr Bolster described blunt force trauma injuries to Bob's scalp, neck and thyroid cartilage, fractured ribs and internal lacerations. (kildarenow.com)
- whatDr Bolster could not rule out the possibility that more than one person was responsible for Bob's injuries. (kildarenow.com)
- whatBob was just short of his 50th birthday when he died and worked in construction. (kildarenow.com)
- whatThe pathologist described blunt force trauma injuries to the scalp, neck and thyroid cartilage, fractured ribs and internal lacerations. (kilkennypeople.ie)
- whatThe pathologist could not rule out the possibility that more than one person was responsible for Bob's injuries. (kilkennypeople.ie)
- whatThe victim sent a large portion of the casino winnings to Romania via a friend before the attack. (irishtimes.com)
- whatCCTV will show the accused and the deceased in an increasingly intoxicated state travelling from Dublin city centre by Luas to Tallaght. (irishtimes.com)
- whatThe victim held up four fingers when asked if he had been attacked. (irishtimes.com)
- whatThe victim had lived a transient life in Ireland and had slept in his car for a time. (irishtimes.com)
- whatBob was brought to Tallaght Hospital where he later died (irishtimes.com)
- whatBob was found by Polish woman Marzana Jurzak as she walked her dog (irishtimes.com)
- whatIn the days before his death Bob had won €2-3,000 at a Dublin casino (irishtimes.com)
- whatBob was awake but moaning and repeatedly asking for water when paramedics arrived (irishtimes.com)
- whatBob went into respiratory arrest upon arrival at Tallaght Hospital and later suffered cardiac arrest (irishtimes.com, thejournal.ie)
- whatBob had a swollen face and blood coming from his mouth when first seen by paramedics (irishtimes.com)
- whatBeer bottles and cans were at the scene but no smell of alcohol was detected on Bob (irishtimes.com)
- whatAn identity card was discovered on Bob and staff rang Tallaght Garda Station (irishtimes.com)
- whatCCTV showed Bob in Dublin city centre with another male, both took the Luas to Tallaght and entered the park in the early hours of 13 April (irishtimes.com)
- whatThe male was later seen returning from the park but Bob does not reappear on CCTV (irishtimes.com)
- whatBob had lived a transient life in Ireland and had slept in his car for a time (irishtimes.com)
- whatBob sent a large portion of the casino winnings to Romania via a friend before he was attacked (irishtimes.com)
- whatWhen asked if he was okay, Bob just showed four fingers (irishtimes.com)
- whatJurzak formed the impression Bob was communicating that there were four attackers (irishtimes.com)
- whatA witness collapsed while giving evidence at the Central Criminal Court on Tuesday 22 March 2022 (irishtimes.com)
- whatThe witness was Romanian woman Garofita Selin (irishtimes.com)
- whatShe was being cross-examined by defence counsel Padraig Dwyer SC (irishtimes.com)
- whatIoan Artene Bob was a construction worker found in Sean Walsh Memorial Park in Tallaght, Dublin 24 (irishtimes.com)
- whatBob was found lying in the shrub area of the park by a dog-walker on the morning of 13 April (irishtimes.com)
- whatBob was taken to Tallaght Hospital where he later died (irishtimes.com)
- whatMs Selin was the only witness giving evidence in court that day (irishtimes.com)
- whatShe collapsed from her chair in the witness box at around 3.55pm (irishtimes.com)
- whatShe was attended to by gardaí, security and court staff (irishtimes.com)
- whatShe was giving evidence through an interpreter when she fell unconscious (irishtimes.com)
- whatShe remained on the ground for 35 minutes until emergency services arrived (irishtimes.com)
- whatShe was given oxygen before being taken by wheelchair from the court (irishtimes.com)
- whatMr Dwyer had put it to Ms Selin that Mr Anghel had never acted inappropriately towards her at work (irishtimes.com)
- whatWitness Garofita Selin collapsed unconscious in the witness box at the Central Criminal Court. (thejournal.ie)
- whatSelin was being cross-examined by defence counsel Padraig Dwyer SC. (thejournal.ie)
- whatBob was found lying in the shrub area of the park by a dog-walker on the morning of 13 April and taken to Tallaght Hospital where he later died. (thejournal.ie)
- whatBob had won between €2,000 and €3,000 at a casino in the days before his death. (thejournal.ie)
- whatSelin was attended to by gardaí, security staff and court staff, and remained on the ground for 35 minutes until emergency services arrived. (thejournal.ie)
- whatSelin was given oxygen before being taken by wheelchair from the court. (thejournal.ie)
- whatThe victim was found badly beaten by a woman walking her dog in the park in the morning. (irishtimes.com)
- whatThe victim won up to €2,700 at a casino in Dublin City on 9 April 2018. (irishtimes.com)
- whatThe victim had already sent the bulk of the casino winnings to his family in Romania before being attacked. (irishtimes.com)
- whatCCTV footage showed the victim and the accused together on the night and travelling on a Luas towards the park. (irishtimes.com)
- whatWhen the victim was taken to Tallaght Hospital he had no bank card, cash or phone on him. (irishtimes.com)
- whatThe accused had complained of pain in his hands because he had hit a friend while drinking the night before. (irishtimes.com)
- whatThere was no DNA, fingerprint or fibre evidence in the case. (irishtimes.com)
- whatFeri Anghel is 42, of no fixed abode, and originally from Romania (rte.ie)
- whatThe victim was 49 years old (rte.ie)
- whatMr Bob had worked in construction (rte.ie)
- whatMr Bob was living a transient life in Dublin city at the time of his death (rte.ie)
- whatMr Bob had slept in his car for a time (rte.ie)
- whatMr Bob won around €2,700 at a Dublin city centre casino in the days before his death (rte.ie)
- whatMr Bob sent a large portion of the casino winnings home to his family (rte.ie)
- whatMr Bob was found badly beaten by a woman walking her dog in the park (rte.ie)
- whatMr Bob later died at Tallaght University Hospital (rte.ie)
- whatMr Bob suffered a broken nose, extensive bruising to the top of his head, a broken jaw and several broken teeth (rte.ie)
- whatMultiple lacerations and bruises to the neck, arms, hands and face were visible (rte.ie)
- whatMr Bob's lungs had collapsed after multiple ribs became fractured (rte.ie)
- whatA badly beaten Bob was found by a woman walking her dog in Sean Walsh Memorial Park in the early hours of 13 April 2018. (irishtimes.com)
- whatBob went into respiratory arrest on arrival at Tallaght Hospital and later suffered cardiac arrest. (irishtimes.com)
- whatThe autopsy found a broken nose, extensive bruising to the top of the head, a broken jaw, several broken teeth, and multiple lacerations and bruises to the neck, arms, hands and face. (irishtimes.com)
- whatCCTV showed Bob and Anghel together on the night of 12 April and travelling on a Luas towards the park. (irishtimes.com, thejournal.ie)
- whatWhen Bob was taken to Tallaght Hospital he had no bank card, cash or phone on him. (irishtimes.com)
- whatA badly beaten Bob was found by a woman out walking her dog in Sean Walsh Memorial Park in the early hours of 13 April 2018. (thejournal.ie)
- whatThe pathologist found a broken nose, extensive bruising to the top of the head, a broken jaw, and several broken teeth. (thejournal.ie)
- whatBob had no bank card, cash or phone on him when taken to Tallaght Hospital. (thejournal.ie)
- whatThe victim was a construction worker. (rte.ie)
- whatThe victim was a father of one with a 12-year-old son named Ionut. (rte.ie)
- whatThe victim had won around €2,700 at a casino in Dublin city centre on 9 April 2018. (rte.ie)
- whatThe victim had sent the bulk of the casino winnings to his family in Romania before being attacked. (rte.ie)
- whatThe victim was taken to Tallaght Hospital by ambulance and died the same day. (rte.ie)
- whatThe convicted man was 43 years old and of no fixed abode. (rte.ie)
- whatThe attack was described as a 'stamping' type attack that was extremely violent and vicious. (rte.ie)
- whatThe convicted man had cynically lured the victim to the park towards the early hours of 13 April 2018. (rte.ie)
- whereBob was found in Sean Walsh Park, Tallaght, Dublin 24, on the morning of 13 April 2018. (longfordleader.ie)
- whereDumitru saw Bob outside a casino on O'Connell Street, Dublin 1, the night before Bob was found in the park. (longfordleader.ie)
- whereBob told Dumitru he had gone to a casino on Eden Quay with the €2 and won over €2,500. (kildarenow.com)
- whereDumitru saw Bob outside a casino on O'Connell Street, Dublin 1, the night before he was found in the park, where Bob was with friends and drinking. (kildarenow.com)
- whereDumitru met up again with Bob on Moore Street, where Bob was drunk with friends from Romania, and Dumitru left because Bob did not speak nice to him. (kildarenow.com)
- whereBob was found in a park in Tallaght, Dublin 24 (irishtimes.com)
- whereBob was found in Sean Walsh Park, Tallaght, Dublin 24, by passers-by on the morning of 13 April 2018. (thejournal.ie)
- whereThe murder took place at a location in County Dublin (irishtimes.com)
- whereIoan Artene Bob was found dying in the early morning at Seán Walsh Park in Tallaght. (irishtimes.com)
- whereIoan Artene Bob was found by passersby in Sean Walsh Park in Tallaght, south Dublin, in the early hours. (irishtimes.com, kildarenow.com, kilkennypeople.ie)
- whereThe victim was found in Sean Walsh Memorial Park, Tallaght, Dublin 24. (irishtimes.com)
- whereBob was found in Sean Walsh Memorial Park, Tallaght, Dublin 24 (irishtimes.com)
- whereBoth the witness and the accused were working as cleaners in Slane, Co Meath, at the time of the alleged incident (irishtimes.com)
- whereBoth Selin and Anghel were working as cleaners in Slane, Co Meath, at the time of the alleged incident. (thejournal.ie)
- whereIoan Artene Bob was found in Sean Walsh Memorial Park in Tallaght, Dublin 24. (thejournal.ie)
- whereThe murder took place in Sean Walsh Memorial Park, Tallaght, Dublin (rte.ie)
- whereThe victim was found lying in undergrowth at Sean Walsh Memorial Park in Tallaght. (rte.ie)
- whereThe body was found by walkers at Sean Walsh Memorial Park in Tallaght (thejournal.ie)
- whenAt 11pm the night before Bob died, Dumitru phoned Bob but it rang out, and subsequent calls went to voicemail. (longfordleader.ie, kildarenow.com)
- whenBob was found on the morning of 13 April 2018 (irishtimes.com)
- whenBob visited Ciocirla's house at about 7pm on 12 April 2018 (irishtimes.com)
- whenThe murder took place at a location in County Dublin on 13 April 2018. (kildarenow.com)
- whenArtene Bob was found injured and dying in Sean Walsh Park at about 7:30am. (kildarenow.com)
- whenThe murder occurred at a location in County Dublin on 13 April 2018 (kilkennypeople.ie)
- whenThe murder took place on 13 April 2018 (irishtimes.com)
- whenBob was found at about 7.30am on 13 April 2018 in Sean Walsh Park. (irishtimes.com, kildarenow.com, kilkennypeople.ie)
- whenThe witness found the victim at around 7.45am on Friday, April 13, 2018. (irishtimes.com)
- whenBob was pronounced dead at 4.37pm on 13 April 2018 (irishtimes.com)
- whenThe collapse occurred at around 3.55pm on 22 March 2022. (thejournal.ie)
- whenThe murder occurred in the early hours of 13 April 2018 (rte.ie)
- whenThe victim was found on the morning of 13 April 2018. (rte.ie)
- whenIoan Artene Bob was found lying in undergrowth on the morning of 13 April 2018 (thejournal.ie)
- causeBob died from extensive blunt force trauma, with multiple fractures and bruising to his lungs and the outer surface of the heart. (kildarenow.com, irishtimes.com, thejournal.ie)
- causeAssistant State Pathologist Dr Margot Bolster said Bob died from blunt force trauma. (irishtimes.com, kildarenow.com, kilkennypeople.ie)
- causeThe cause of death will be shown to be blunt force trauma. (irishtimes.com)
- causeThe victim died from cardiac arrest due to his injuries at Tallaght Hospital later that day. (irishtimes.com)
- causeThe victim died from extensive blunt force trauma with multiple fractures and bruising to his lungs and the outer surface of the heart. (irishtimes.com)
- causeGardaí believed a possible motive was connected to a casino win (thejournal.ie)
- investigationDr Margot Bolster carried out the post-mortem examination (rte.ie)
- investigationCCTV played a vital role in the case. (rte.ie)
- chargeFeri Anghel, 40, is charged with murdering Bob at a location in Co Dublin on 13 April 2018 and has pleaded not guilty. (longfordleader.ie)
- chargeFeri Anghel, 40, is charged with murdering Bob at a location in County Dublin on 13 April 2018 and has pleaded not guilty at the Central Criminal Court. (kildarenow.com)
- chargeFeri Anghel has pleaded not guilty to the murder charge (irishtimes.com)
- chargeFeri Anghel, aged 40, pleaded not guilty to murdering Romanian national Ioan Artene Bob, aged 49. (kildarenow.com)
- chargeAnghel pleaded not guilty to murdering Ioan Artene Bob (kilkennypeople.ie)
- chargeFeri Anghel, 40, a member of the Romani community, pleaded not guilty to murdering Ioan Artene Bob, 49 (irishtimes.com)
- chargeFeri Anghel, a member of the Romani community, has pleaded not guilty to murdering Ioan Artene Bob. (irishtimes.com)
- chargeFeri Anghel, aged 40, pleaded not guilty to murder at the Central Criminal Court. (irishtimes.com, kildarenow.com)
- chargeFeri Anghel, 40, pleaded not guilty to the murder of Ioan Artene Bob at the Central Criminal Court. (kilkennypeople.ie)
- chargeThe prosecution say the person who used the victim's phone and bank card is Feri Anghel. (irishtimes.com)
- chargeFeri Anghel (42) of no fixed abode denies the murder of Bob (irishtimes.com)
- chargeThe prosecution says the person who used Bob's phone and bank card is Mr Anghel (irishtimes.com)
- chargeFeri Anghel is charged with murdering Ioan Artene Bob on 13 April 2018 and has pleaded not guilty (irishtimes.com)
- chargeFeri Anghel, 42, is charged with murdering Ioan Artene Bob, 49, in Co Dublin on 13 April 2018 and has pleaded not guilty. (thejournal.ie)
- chargeFeri Anghel, 42, of no fixed abode, pleaded not guilty to the murder of Ioan Artene Bob. (irishtimes.com)
- chargeAnghel pleaded not guilty to the murder charge (rte.ie)
- courtThe trial is before Ms Justice Eileen Creedon and a jury of eight men and four women, expected to last five weeks. (longfordleader.ie)
- courtThe trial is before Ms Justice Eileen Creedon and a jury of eight men and four women and is expected to last five weeks. (kildarenow.com)
- courtThe trial is before Ms Justice Eileen Creedon and a jury of eight men and four women (irishtimes.com)
- courtThe trial is expected to last five weeks (irishtimes.com)
- courtThe prosecution began its closing speech in the trial at the Central Criminal Court. (thejournal.ie)
- courtThe jury consisted of six men and four women. (thejournal.ie)
- courtThe jury consisted of eight men and four women at the Central Criminal Court. (kildarenow.com)
- courtJudge Eileen Creedon was to deliver her charge to the jury the following day. (kildarenow.com)
- courtThe trial jury consists of eight men and four women at the Central Criminal Court (kilkennypeople.ie)
- courtMs Justice Eileen Creedon will deliver her charge to the jury (kilkennypeople.ie)
- courtA Central Criminal Court jury began deliberating in the trial of Feri Anghel for the murder of a Romanian man in a Dublin park (irishtimes.com)
- courtJudge Eileen Creedon presided and addressed a jury of six men and four women (irishtimes.com)
- courtThree possible verdicts were available: guilty of murder, not guilty, or not guilty of murder but guilty of manslaughter (irishtimes.com)
- courtThe prosecution presented a circumstantial case (irishtimes.com)
- courtThe jury was instructed to consider the cumulative weight of evidence and whether it proved beyond a reasonable doubt that the accused committed the crime (irishtimes.com)
- courtMurder is defined under the Criminal Justice Act 1964 as an unlawful killing where the accused intended to kill or cause serious injury (irishtimes.com)
- courtThe jury was to return to court on Thursday to continue deliberating (irishtimes.com)
- courtThe jury will return to the Central Criminal Court on Friday to continue deliberating. (irishtimes.com)
- courtJudge Eileen Creedon told the jury of four women and six men that three verdicts are available: not guilty, guilty of murder, or not guilty of murder but guilty of manslaughter. (irishtimes.com)
- courtThe jury was sent home at 1pm on Thursday. (irishtimes.com)
- courtThe jury failed to reach a verdict in the trial. (irishtimes.com)
- courtThe trial was expected to last five weeks but finished after three months. (irishtimes.com, kildarenow.com, kilkennypeople.ie)
- courtThe jury was reduced from 12 to ten people during the trial. (irishtimes.com, kildarenow.com)
- courtJudge Eillen Creedon told the remaining jurors there was no option for a majority verdict. (irishtimes.com)
- courtThree possible verdicts were open to the jury: guilty, not guilty, or not guilty of murder but guilty of manslaughter. (irishtimes.com)
- courtProsecution counsel Paul Greene SC asked the judge to adjourn until October 4 for a possible retrial. (irishtimes.com, kildarenow.com)
- courtThe jury failed to reach a verdict in the murder trial. (kildarenow.com)
- courtThe defence applied for the jury to be dismissed when a witness in the Book of Evidence was not called to testify. (kildarenow.com)
- courtThe witness had attended court three times but was not called due to his intoxication. (kildarenow.com, kilkennypeople.ie)
- courtOn one occasion the witness tried to step over the sixth floor balcony inside the Criminal Courts of Justice building. (kildarenow.com, kilkennypeople.ie)
- courtJudge Eileen Creedon told jurors there was no option for a majority verdict. (kildarenow.com)
- courtThree possible verdicts were open: guilty, not guilty, or not guilty of murder but guilty of manslaughter. (kildarenow.com)
- courtAfter three days of deliberations the jury foreman said they were too far apart to reach agreement. (kildarenow.com, kilkennypeople.ie)
- courtThe jury failed to reach a verdict in the murder trial after three months. (kilkennypeople.ie)
- courtThe defence applied for the jury to be dismissed when a Book of Evidence witness was not called to testify. (kilkennypeople.ie)
- courtThe jury was reduced from 12 to ten people during the trial, leaving no option for a majority verdict. (kilkennypeople.ie)
- courtThe judge told jurors there were three possible verdicts: guilty, not guilty, or not guilty of murder but guilty of manslaughter. (kilkennypeople.ie)
- courtThe prosecution asked the court to adjourn until October 4 to allow lawyers to take instructions regarding a possible retrial. (kilkennypeople.ie)
- courtThe trial is being heard at the Central Criminal Court before Mr Justice Paul Burns and a jury of four women and eight men. (irishtimes.com)
- courtThe trial is before Mr Justice Paul Burns and a jury of four women and eight men (irishtimes.com)
- courtMr Justice Paul Burns sent the jury home and adjourned the case for the rest of the day (irishtimes.com)
- courtMr Justice Paul Burns sent the jury home and adjourned the case until the following day. (thejournal.ie)
- courtThe jury can return a verdict of manslaughter if satisfied he carried out the attack but not that he intended to kill. (irishtimes.com)
- courtIt was not contested by either side that the killing was unlawful. (irishtimes.com)
- courtA jury of eight men and four women returned a unanimous guilty verdict (rte.ie)
- courtThe jury deliberated for three hours and 44 minutes (rte.ie)
- courtThe trial began at the Central Criminal Court seven weeks before the verdict (rte.ie)
- courtAnghel was remanded in custody until 30 May for sentencing (rte.ie)
- courtA jury of eight men and three women returned a unanimous guilty verdict after three hours and 44 minutes of deliberation. (irishtimes.com)
- courtThe trial opened at the Central Criminal Court seven weeks before the verdict. (irishtimes.com, thejournal.ie)
- courtMr Justice Paul Burns remanded Anghel in custody until 30 May 2022 for sentencing. (irishtimes.com)
- courtDefence counsel Padraig Dwyer SC described Anghel as a Romanian gypsy and referenced the Birmingham Six and Guildford Four. (irishtimes.com)
- courtA jury of eight men and four women returned a unanimous verdict of guilty on the murder charge. (thejournal.ie)
- courtMr Justice Paul Burns remanded Anghel in custody until 30 May for sentencing. (thejournal.ie)
- courtThe convicted man was unanimously convicted by a Central Criminal Court jury on 14 April 2022. (rte.ie)
- courtA previous jury had failed to reach a verdict in August 2021. (rte.ie)
- courtAnghel had pleaded not guilty but was unanimously convicted by a jury on 14 April 2022 (thejournal.ie)
- courtMr Justice Burns did not allow Anghel to address the court (thejournal.ie)
- sentenceThe convicted man was sentenced to the mandatory life sentence. (rte.ie)
- sentenceThe life sentence was backdated to 18 April 2018. (rte.ie)
- sentenceFeri Anghel was sentenced to life imprisonment at the Central Criminal Court (thejournal.ie)
- sentenceThe life sentence was backdated to 18 April 2018 when Anghel first went into custody (thejournal.ie)
- otherCiocirla and Bob were childhood neighbours in Romania and met by coincidence on Grafton Street in 2017 (irishtimes.com)
- otherThere was no forensic evidence to link the accused to Sean Walsh Park. (thejournal.ie)
- otherThere was no weapon to link the accused to the death and no boots before the court. (thejournal.ie)
- otherNo exact time was offered on when the attack on Bob occurred. (thejournal.ie)
- otherCCTV showed Anghel leading Artene Bob onto a Luas tram shortly after midnight. (kildarenow.com, kilkennypeople.ie)
- otherTwo men dressed similarly to those on the Luas footage were captured in Tallaght walking towards Sean Walsh Park. (kildarenow.com, kilkennypeople.ie)
- otherThe deceased had recently won money at a casino and had €400 in his wallet. (kildarenow.com, kilkennypeople.ie)
- otherWhen found, Artene Bob had no cash, no phone, and his ATM card was missing. (kildarenow.com)
- otherA man uncannily similar to the accused was captured at The Square in Tallaght attempting to withdraw cash from an ATM using the deceased's bank card. (kildarenow.com)
- otherThe following day the accused used the deceased's ATM card for two tap transactions at a Gala shop and a Topaz garage in Slane, Co Meath. (kildarenow.com)
- otherThere was evidence that Anghel was in possession of the deceased's phone. (kildarenow.com, kilkennypeople.ie)
- otherThe accused lied to gardaí when interviewed as a suspect for the murder. (kildarenow.com)
- otherForensic evidence included DNA belonging to two unknown people on the deceased's glasses. (kildarenow.com, kilkennypeople.ie)
- otherThe woman who found Artene Bob asked him who did this to him and he put up four fingers. (kildarenow.com)
- otherNobody knows what happened to Artene Bob between entering the park at about 1am and being found at 7:30am. (kildarenow.com)
- otherBob was just short of his 50th birthday when he died and was a Romanian national who worked in construction. (kilkennypeople.ie)
- otherBob won €2,700 on a gambling machine at an arcade on O'Connell Street not long before his death. (kilkennypeople.ie)
- otherBob had won between €200 and €300 at a casino in the days before his death (irishtimes.com)
- otherBob had sent the bulk of the casino winnings to his family in Romania the day before he was attacked (irishtimes.com, thejournal.ie)
- otherAnghel had been working as an office cleaner at the time of his arrest. (irishtimes.com)
- otherBob sent a large portion of the casino winnings home to his family before the attack. (irishtimes.com, thejournal.ie)
- otherAnghel was working as an office cleaner at the time of his arrest. (thejournal.ie)
- otherThe convicted man had 24 previous convictions from Romania, France and Ireland, 11 of which came from Irish courts. (rte.ie)
- otherThe convicted man's criminal record included attempted murder in Romania, aggravated theft, criminal damage, violent behaviour in a garda station, and road traffic offences. (rte.ie)
- otherThe victim had six sisters and three brothers who were profoundly shocked by his murder. (rte.ie)
- otherThe victim would send home around €200 a week for his 12-year-old son. (rte.ie)
- otherBob won around €2,700 at a casino in Dublin city centre on 9 April 2018 (thejournal.ie)
- otherBob had already sent the bulk of the money to his family in Romania (thejournal.ie)
- otherBob was taken to Tallaght Hospital by ambulance and died later the same day (thejournal.ie)
- otherAnghel had 24 previous convictions from Romania, France and Ireland (thejournal.ie)
- other11 of Anghel's convictions came from Irish courts (thejournal.ie)
- otherBob would send home around €200 a week for his 12-year-old son Ionut (thejournal.ie)
- otherFamily members still suffered panic attacks and psychological damage, with some unable to return to work (thejournal.ie)
The reporting
newest first- 30 May2022Man sentenced to life for 'vicious and cynical' murder of homeless father of one
Reports the full sentencing hearing details: the judge's remarks describing the 'stamping' type attack, the family statement read by Det Sgt Palmer, Anghel's 24 previous convictions from Romania, France and Ireland, the backdating of the sentence to 18 April 2018, and Anghel's outburst towards the family as he was led away.
victim, Ioan Artene Bob, 49, male, Romanian, non-irishIoan Artene Bobconvicted, Feri Anghel, 43, male, named, non-irish (judged from name)Feri Anghel - 30 May2022Man given life sentence over Dublin park murder
Reports the sentencing of Feri Anghel to a mandatory life sentence (backdated to 18 April 2018) for the murder of Ioan Artene Bob, including details of the crime, trial history, the victim's background, the judge's remarks, and the family's statement.
victim, Ioan Artene Bob, 49, male, Romanian, non-irishIoan Artene Bobconvicted, Feri Anghel, 43, male, Romanian, named, non-irishFeri Anghel - 14 Apr2022Man found guilty of murdering homeless man in Dublin in 2018
Reports the guilty verdict at the second trial, details of the jury composition and deliberation time, witness testimony including the pathologist's findings, CCTV evidence, and prosecution and defence closing arguments.
victim, Ioan Artene Bob, 49, male, Romanian, non-irishIoan Artene Bobconvicted, Feri Anghel, 42, male, Romanian, named, non-irishFeri Anghel - 14 Apr2022Jury returns guilty verdict in Tallaght park murder case
Reports the unanimous guilty verdict, details of trial evidence including CCTV, witness and medical testimony, the defence's arguments about prejudice, and the remand for sentencing on 30 May 2022.
victim, Ioan Artene Bob, 49, male, Romanian, non-irishIoan Artene Bobconvicted, Feri Anghel, 42, male, Romanian, named, non-irishFeri Anghel - 14 Apr2022Man found guilty over 2018 Dublin park murder
Reports the guilty verdict, jury composition and deliberation time, post-mortem findings by Dr Margot Bolster, CCTV evidence of Anghel using Bob's bank card, and remand for sentencing.
victim, Ioan Artene Bob, 49, male, Romanian, non-irishIoan Artene Bobconvicted, Feri Anghel, 42, male, Romanian, named, non-irishFeri Anghel - 13 Apr2022Jury told it can return manslaughter verdict in trial of man accused of murder
Reports the judge's charge to the jury and closing speeches, including the instruction that a manslaughter verdict is open if intent to kill is not proven, and details of the circumstantial prosecution case.
victim, Ioan Artene Bob, 49, male, Romanian, non-irishIoan Artene Bobaccused, Feri Anghel, 42, male, Romanian, named, non-irishFeri Anghel - 22 Mar2022Witness collapses at Central Criminal Court murder trial
Reports that witness Garofita Selin collapsed during cross-examination on 22 March 2022, that the defence is arguing contradictions in her statements between Ireland and Romania, and that the court heard Bob had won €2,000–€3,000 at a casino but sent most of it to his family in Romania the day before his death. The trial was adjourned by Mr Justice Paul Burns.
victim, Ioan Artene Bob, 49, male, Romanian, non-irishIoan Artene Bobaccused, Feri Anghel, 42, male, Romanian, named, non-irishFeri Anghel - 22 Mar2022Witness collapses at Central Criminal Court murder trial
Reports the collapse of witness Garofita Selin during cross-examination by Padraig Dwyer SC, details about the witness's testimony regarding Anghel's behaviour, the cause of death of the victim, and the court's adjournment by Mr Justice Paul Burns.
victim, Ioan Artene Bob, 49, male, Romanian, non-irishIoan Artene Bobaccused, Feri Anghel, 42, male, Romanian, named, non-irishFeri Anghel - 10 Mar2022Badly beaten man found with severe bruising to eyes and face, murder trial hears
Trial testimony from paramedics, witnesses, and CCTV evidence describing Bob's injuries, the circumstances of being found in the park, and the prosecution's case that Anghel used Bob's phone and bank card after the attack.
victim, Ioan Artene Bob, 49, male, Romanian, non-irishIoan Artene Bobaccused, Feri Anghel, 42, male, named, non-irish (judged from name)Feri Anghel - 9 Mar2022Man who died after attack had ‘stroke of luck’ at a casino, trial told
Trial proceedings: witness testimony from Marzana Jurzak describing how she found the victim, prosecution opening speech detailing the casino win, use of the victim's phone and bank card, and CCTV evidence of both men travelling by Luas to Tallaght.
victim, Ioan Artene Bob, 49, male, Romanian, non-irishIoan Artene Bobaccused, Feri Anghel, 42, male, named, non-irish (judged from name)Feri Anghel - 17 Aug2021Jury fails to reach verdict in murder trial
Reports that the jury in the Central Criminal Court trial of Feri Anghel for the murder of Ioan Artene Bob failed to reach a unanimous verdict after three months. Details the prosecution and defence closing arguments, the pathologist's evidence, CCTV evidence, and the adjournment to 4 October for a possible retrial.
victim, Ioan Artene Bob, 49, male, Romanian, non-irishIoan Artene Bobaccused, Feri Anghel, 40, male, named, non-irish (judged from name)Feri Anghel - 17 Aug2021Jury fails to reach verdict in murder trial
Reports that the jury failed to reach a unanimous verdict after three months of trial, the matter was adjourned to 4 October 2021 for possible retrial, and provides detailed evidence including CCTV footage, pathologist testimony, and defence arguments about the presence of other people in the park.
victim, Ioan Artene Bob, 49, male, Romanian, non-irishIoan Artene Bobaccused, Feri Anghel, 40, male, Romanian, named, non-irishFeri Anghel - 16 Aug2021Jury fails to reach verdict in trial over alleged murder in Dublin park
Reports that the jury (reduced from 12 to 10) failed to reach a unanimous verdict after three days of deliberations; the trial, expected to last five weeks, finished after three months; the matter was adjourned to 4 October 2021 for instructions on a possible retrial. Includes detailed evidence presented at trial including CCTV, forensic findings, and defence arguments.
victim, Ioan Artene Bob, 49, male, Romanian, non-irishIoan Artene Bobaccused, Feri Anghel, 40, male, Romanian, named, non-irishFeri Anghel - 12 Aug2021Jury to resume deliberations in murder trial on Friday
Reports that the jury was sent home at 1pm on Thursday and will resume deliberations on Friday, and that Judge Creedon outlined the three available verdicts to the jury of four women and six men.
victim, Ioan Artene Bob, 49, male, Romanian, non-irishIoan Artene Bobaccused, Feri Anghel, 40, male, Romanian, named, non-irishFeri Anghel - 11 Aug2021Jury begins deliberations in trial over Dublin park murder
Reports that the jury has begun deliberations, the judge's direction on the three possible verdicts (murder, not guilty, or manslaughter), and that the prosecution's case is circumstantial. Jury to return Thursday to continue.
accused, Feri Anghel, 40, male, named, non-irish (judged from name)Feri Anghelvictim, Ioan Artene Bob, 49, male, Romanian, non-irishIoan Artene Bob - 11 Aug2021Jury asked to put prejudice out of their minds in murder trial
Reports closing arguments in the trial: defence urged not guilty citing reasonable doubt, alternative scenarios and DNA of two unknown people; prosecution presented CCTV of Anghel leading victim onto Luas tram, ATM card usage in Tallaght and Slane, possession of victim's phone, and the victim's dying gesture of four fingers.
victim, Ioan Artene Bob, 49, male, Romanian, non-irishIoan Artene Bobaccused, Feri Anghel, 40, male, Romanian, named, non-irishFeri Anghel - 10 Aug2021Jury asked to put prejudice out of their minds in murder trial
Closing arguments in the Central Criminal Court trial; defence urged a not-guilty verdict citing reasonable doubt, alternative scenarios and DNA from two unknown people; prosecution presented CCTV of Anghel leading the victim onto a Luas tram, ATM card usage in Tallaght and Slane, and possession of the victim's phone; judge to deliver charge to jury the following day.
victim, Ioan Artene Bob, 49, male, Romanian, non-irishIoan Artene Bobaccused, Feri Anghel, 40, male, Romanian, named, non-irishFeri Anghel - 9 Aug2021Jury hears closing speech in trial of man accused of murdering homeless construction worker
Reports the prosecution's closing speech in the trial, detailing the circumstantial evidence presented to the jury: phone proximity data, AIB card transactions, CCTV of the Luas journey and ATM attempts, the absence of forensic evidence or a weapon, and the pathologist's findings of blunt-force trauma. The defence closing speech by Padraig Dwyer SC was to follow the next day.
victim, Ioan Artene Bob, 49, male, Romanian, non-irishIoan Artene Bobaccused, Feri Anghel, 40, male, Romanian, named, non-irishFeri Anghel - 8 Jul2021Man sent casino winnings to brother abroad on day before killed, trial told
Trial testimony detailing Bob's casino winnings, the €2,600 he gave to a friend to take to his brother in Romania, the cause and nature of his fatal injuries, and his personal circumstances including sleeping in his car.
victim, Ioan Artene Bob, 49, male, non-irish (judged from name)Ioan Artene Bobaccused, Feri Anghel, 40, male, named, non-irish (judged from name)Feri Anghel - 8 Jul2021Witness tells murder trial that days before he died, his friend 'hit the jackpot' at casino
Reports testimony from witness Marian Dumitru at the Central Criminal Court trial, including details about Bob's casino win, his sleeping arrangements, his eight-year-old daughter in Spain, and his interactions with Dumitru the night before his death. Also details the cause of death and the prosecution's opening speech.
victim, Ioan Artene Bob, 49, male, Romanian, non-irishIoan Artene Bobaccused, Feri Anghel, 40, male, Romanian, named, non-irishFeri Anghel - 8 Jul2021Witness tells murder trial that days before he died, his friend 'hit the jackpot' at casino
Reports testimony from witness Marian Dumitru at the Central Criminal Court trial, detailing Bob's final days including a casino win, his drinking, and his request for a knife the night before he was found beaten.
victim, Ioan Artene Bob, 49, male, Romanian, non-irishIoan Artene Bobaccused, Feri Anghel, 40, male, Romanian, named, non-irishFeri Anghel